More of Sanibel's Standout Tables
A deeper pass through the restaurants keeping Sanibel in the national dining conversation, from buzzy newcomers to long-game institutions.
Parrot Key Caribbean Grill
Sanibel, Florida
4.4 stars from 2,388 reviews for this caribbean restaurant address in Sanibel.
Traders Restaurant on Sanibel
Sanibel, Florida
4.4 stars from 792 reviews for this restaurant address in Sanibel.
The Whale
Sanibel, Florida
4.4 stars from 1,684 reviews for this bar & grill address in Sanibel.
The Bubble Room Restaurant
Sanibel, Florida
4.3 stars from 2,971 reviews for this american restaurant address in Sanibel.
Island View
Sanibel, Florida
4.3 stars from 555 reviews for this seafood restaurant address in Sanibel.
Blue Giraffe Island Bar and Grill
Sanibel, Florida
4.5 stars from 1,125 reviews for this restaurant address in Sanibel.
Old Captiva House
Sanibel, Florida
4.6 stars from 553 reviews for this seafood restaurant address in Sanibel.
The Original Cheeburger Cheeburger
Sanibel, Florida
4.2 stars from 1,247 reviews for this bar & grill address in Sanibel.
Cabanas Beach Bar & Grille
Sanibel, Florida
4.5 stars from 453 reviews for this american restaurant address in Sanibel.
Sanibel Deli & Coffee Factory
Sanibel, Florida
4.5 stars from 648 reviews for this restaurant address in Sanibel.
Turtle’s Tiki Bar
Sanibel, Florida
4.5 stars from 268 reviews for this bar & grill address in Sanibel.
Ugly's Waterside Bar
Sanibel, Florida
4.4 stars from 3,621 reviews for this seafood restaurant address in Sanibel.
The Bel Bagels & Deli
Sanibel, Florida
4.8 stars from 120 reviews for this deli address in Sanibel.
Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen
Sanibel, Florida
4.4 stars from 483 reviews for this italian restaurant address in Sanibel.
Thistle Lodge Beachfront Restaurant
Sanibel, Florida
4.2 stars from 478 reviews for this seafood restaurant address in Sanibel.
Bella Mozzarella Pizza & Grill
Sanibel, Florida
4.2 stars from 766 reviews for this pizza restaurant address in Sanibel.
Great White Grill
Sanibel, Florida
4.4 stars from 437 reviews for this restaurant address in Sanibel.
Rosalita's Cantina Sanibel
Sanibel, Florida
4.5 stars from 560 reviews for this restaurant address in Sanibel.
Shima Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi Bar
Sanibel, Florida
4.4 stars from 197 reviews for this japanese steakhouse address in Sanibel.
Mango's Bar & Grill
Sanibel, Florida
4.3 stars from 332 reviews for this bar & grill address in Sanibel.
Nervous Nellie's
Sanibel, Florida
4.4 stars from 3,622 reviews for this seafood restaurant address in Sanibel.
Island Pizza Restaurant
Sanibel, Florida
4.0 stars from 908 reviews for this pizza restaurant address in Sanibel.
The Mad Hatter Restaurant
Sanibel, Florida
4.7 stars from 609 reviews for this new american restaurant address in Sanibel.
Harborside
Sanibel, Florida
4.1 stars from 425 reviews for this steak house address in Sanibel.
The Mucky Duck Restaurant
Sanibel, Florida
4.2 stars from 2,867 reviews for this restaurant address in Sanibel.