25 Essential Bay Shore Institutions
From neighborhood classics to high-wire tasting rooms, these are the places shaping the modern dining identity of Bay Shore.
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering
New York
Seafood & steak specialist in a charming waterfront building with a full bar & Sunday brunch.
Fatty T’s Burger Shack
New York
an everyday essential table known for disciplined hamburger restaurant cooking, strong local gravity, and Beam Score momentum at 80.5.
Local Burger - Bay Shore Restaurant and Bar
New York
Thoughtfully sourced burgers & craft beer in an industrial-chic space with seasonal sidewalk seats.
Goldy's Gems
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: Outdoor seating, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeout, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service, Great beer selection, Great cocktails, Live music.
Buttermilk's Farmhouse
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeout, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service, Great coffee, Serves local specialty. Popular for: Breakfast.
Bella Vie
Bay Shore, New York
Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible seating.
Leggios Deli
Bay Shore, New York
Identifies as LGBTQ+ owned. Service options: Onsite services, Takeout. Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot.
KTO Cuisine
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: No-contact delivery, Delivery, Onsite services, Takeout, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service, Serves local specialty. Popular for: Lunch, Dinner.
Fratelli Pizzeria
Bay Shore, New York
Perennial pizza parlor in a strip mall offering Italian specialties plus wine in cozy, relaxed digs.
Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge
Bay Shore, New York
Trendy, modern Japanese lounge serving sushi, noodles & hibachi fare, plus sake & cocktails.
Cornerstone Deli
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: Onsite services, Takeout. Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible parking lot. Planning: Quick visit. Payments: Credit cards, Debit cards.
Bono's Pizzeria
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: Curbside pickup, Onsite services, Takeout, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service, Serves local specialty. Popular for: Lunch, Dinner.
Ends Meat Eats
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: Outdoor seating, Curbside pickup, Delivery, Onsite services, Takeout, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service. Popular for: Lunch, Dinner.
Ditch - Bay Shore
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: Outdoor seating, Delivery, Takeout, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service, Great beer selection, Great cocktails, Live music.
Galanga
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: Delivery, Takeout, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service. Popular for: Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining. Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible entrance.
Buseto Pizza
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: No-contact delivery, Delivery, Onsite services, Takeout, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service, Serves local specialty. Popular for: Lunch, Dinner.
Five Guys
Bay Shore, New York
Fast-food chain with made-to-order burgers, fries & hot dogs, plus free peanuts while you wait.
The Pie at Salvatore's
Bay Shore, New York
Hopping pizzeria with classic leather booths serving coal-fired Neapolitan pies & more. Cash only.
Golden Star
Bay Shore, New York
Neighborhood restaurant offering a huge menu of traditional Chinese specialties in a casual space.
Bango
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: Curbside pickup, Delivery, Onsite services, Takeout, Dine-in. Popular for: Lunch, Solo dining. Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible entrance.
Crossroads Que
Bay Shore, New York
Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible parking lot.
The Penny Pub
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: Delivery, Onsite services, Takeout, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service, Great cocktails. Popular for: Solo dining. Accessibility. Offerings.
Golden Chicken in bay shore
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: Delivery, Takeout, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service, Serves local specialty. Popular for: Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining. Accessibility.
Peking Kitchen
Bay Shore, New York
Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot.
WM Burger Shack and Wings
Bay Shore, New York
Service options: Delivery, Onsite services, Dine-in. Highlights: Fast service. Popular for: Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining. Accessibility.