More of Middletown's Standout Tables
A deeper pass through the restaurants keeping Middletown in the national dining conversation, from buzzy newcomers to long-game institutions.
Mattingly's Tavern
Middletown, New York
4.3 stars from 166 reviews for this restaurant address in Middletown.
Las Mañanitas Mexican
Middletown, New York
4.7 stars from 384 reviews for this restaurant address in Middletown.
Pharmacy Kitchen & Bar
Middletown, New York
4.0 stars from 427 reviews for this restaurant address in Middletown.
Americana Diner
Middletown, New York
4.3 stars from 2,175 reviews for this american restaurant address in Middletown.
Franzel
Middletown, New York
4.5 stars from 202 reviews for this german restaurant address in Middletown.
Peru Cuisine Bar&Grill
Middletown, New York
4.1 stars from 515 reviews for this peruvian restaurant address in Middletown.
CHICK E RIBS BBQ llc Wednesday-Sunday
Middletown, New York
4.7 stars from 223 reviews for this barbecue restaurant address in Middletown.
Pasta D’oro At The Jolly Onion
Middletown, New York
4.3 stars from 866 reviews for this restaurant address in Middletown.
Stella 2
Middletown, New York
4.3 stars from 412 reviews for this pizza restaurant address in Middletown.
Dobbins' Tavern at the Stagecoach Inn in Goshen, NY
Middletown, New York
4.7 stars from 19 reviews for this american restaurant address in Middletown.
Pine Bush Deli and Pizza
Middletown, New York
4.4 stars from 243 reviews for this deli address in Middletown.
Franico's Ristorante Pizzeria
Middletown, New York
4.6 stars from 167 reviews for this pizza restaurant address in Middletown.
Alondra’s Pizzeria
Middletown, New York
5.0 stars from 8 reviews for this pizza delivery address in Middletown.
Umi Hot Pot Sushi & Seafood Buffet
Middletown, New York
4.6 stars from 1,216 reviews for this buffet restaurant address in Middletown.
Boosur Meat & Deli
Middletown, New York
4.5 stars from 202 reviews for this restaurant address in Middletown.
Olivia's Empanadas
Middletown, New York
4.8 stars from 372 reviews for this dominican restaurant address in Middletown.
Smokin Grate BBQ LLC
Middletown, New York
4.8 stars from 34 reviews for this mobile caterer address in Middletown.
Pochuck Valley Farm Market & Deli
Middletown, New York
4.6 stars from 338 reviews for this deli address in Middletown.
House of Birria Tacos & Cantina
Middletown, New York
4.5 stars from 348 reviews for this restaurant address in Middletown.
Pizza E Birra
Middletown, New York
4.4 stars from 714 reviews for this restaurant address in Middletown.
Casa Mia
Middletown, New York
4.3 stars from 437 reviews for this italian restaurant address in Middletown.
Hunan Garden
Middletown, New York
4.1 stars from 175 reviews for this chinese restaurant address in Middletown.
Joey's Pizza (Middletown)
Middletown, New York
4.3 stars from 644 reviews for this pizza restaurant address in Middletown.
Buffalo Wild Wings
Middletown, New York
3.8 stars from 1,432 reviews for this chicken wings restaurant address in Middletown.
The Grill
Middletown, New York
4.5 stars from 197 reviews for this american restaurant address in Middletown.