25 Essential New Albany Institutions

Beam Score 79.7Read guide

Eagles Villa Pizza

Ohio

an everyday essential pizza restaurant address in New Albany, pairing strong guest signals with a Beam Score of 79.7.

Intimate chef counter at a fine dining restaurant

Silver Award

Sandwich shop

Jersey Mike's Subs

Ohio

an everyday essential table known for disciplined sandwich shop cooking, strong local gravity, and Beam Score momentum at 78.3.

Beam Score 78.3Read guide

Atmospheric courtyard restaurant in warm evening light

Bronze Award

Beam Score 77.4Read guide

Elliot's Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap

Ohio

an everyday essential favorite for readers tracking New Albany's most persuasive pizza restaurant rooms, anchored by a Beam Score of 77.4.

Hudson 29 Kitchen + Drink

New Albany, Ohio

4.5 stars from 1,172 reviews for this restaurant address in New Albany.

76.2

Close-up of a bright coastal restaurant dish

Mellow Mushroom New Albany

New Albany, Ohio

4.3 stars from 1,262 reviews for this pizza restaurant address in New Albany.

76.1

Moody restaurant interior with polished service

Center Village Pizza

New Albany, Ohio

4.5 stars from 540 reviews for this pizza restaurant address in New Albany.

75.7

Chef-led tasting counter framed in warm wood

Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

New Albany, Ohio

American restaurant

4.4 stars from 1,153 reviews for this american restaurant address in New Albany.

74.9

Blue Agave

New Albany, Ohio

Mexican restaurant

4.2 stars from 1,287 reviews for this mexican restaurant address in New Albany.

71.8

BrewDog New Albany

New Albany, Ohio

4.0 stars from 1,153 reviews for this restaurant address in New Albany.

70.0

#10

Bendi Wok N' Bar- New Albany

New Albany, Ohio

4.5 stars from 157 reviews for this restaurant address in New Albany.

67.6

#11

Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

New Albany, Ohio

3.6 stars from 788 reviews for this fast food restaurant address in New Albany.

62.1

#12

Tic Tac Taco

New Albany, Ohio

3.7 stars from 109 reviews for this fast food restaurant address in New Albany.

61.7

#13

The New Albany Links Pub

New Albany, Ohio

Bar & grill

4.2 stars from 20 reviews for this bar & grill address in New Albany.

61.6

#14

New Albany

New Albany, Ohio

4.1 stars from 244 reviews for this pizza restaurant address in New Albany.

56.8

#15

Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen

New Albany, Ohio

Chicken restaurant

3.3 stars from 227 reviews for this chicken restaurant address in New Albany.

54.6

#16

Taco Bell

New Albany, Ohio

3.3 stars from 111 reviews for this fast food restaurant address in New Albany.

53.8

#17

Chipotle Mexican Grill

New Albany, Ohio

Mexican restaurant

2.7 stars from 217 reviews for this mexican restaurant address in New Albany.

52.0

#18

Barry Bagels New Albany

New Albany, Ohio

3.8 stars from 22 reviews for this restaurant address in New Albany.

51.7

#19

Wendy's

New Albany, Ohio

3.2 stars from 70 reviews for this fast food restaurant address in New Albany.

50.9

#20

Organic Indian Food LLC

New Albany, Ohio

5.0 stars from 1 reviews for this restaurant address in New Albany.

48.3

#21

McDonald's

New Albany, Ohio

2.6 stars from 90 reviews for this fast food restaurant address in New Albany.

40.1

#22

Maries

New Albany, Ohio

Delivery Restaurant

0 reviews for this delivery restaurant address in New Albany.

30.6

#23

Farmer's Fridge

New Albany, Ohio

Health food restaurant

0 reviews for this health food restaurant address in New Albany.

25.4

#24

Maka Mia Pizza - Pataskala

New Albany, Ohio

0 reviews for this pizza restaurant address in New Albany.

22.4

#25

Freshii

New Albany, Ohio

4.1 stars from 170 reviews for this fast food restaurant address in New Albany.

15.9